Skip to main content

How Come People Resist Great Ideas?

 Promoting Value is Exactly Why No One Is Listening


We live in a world of innovation. Every day something new is created. So why is it then that so many great ideas die?

Sell the features. Sell the benefits. Sell the value. The right way to sell is to show how good your service, product or idea is.

Wrong.

Those things are necessary, but they are not what is essential for new ideas or innovation to catch on.

Changing The Frame

I have spent the majority of my career making things better. Continuous improvement, network design, process re-engineering — it has many different labels.

It’s all the same.

Make changes to what is being done to generate better results.

The single biggest key to my success in implementing new ideas?

Lower the barrier for entry.

We like to believe we are organic computers. Rational to the end. That given the right information and the correct inputs, people will produce the best output.

To get someone to actually change, give up on that idea immediately. In the words of Dan Ariely, humans are predictably irrational.

To succeed with a new idea or implementing radical change, you have to address the resistance people have, in addition to the positive benefits the change brings.

Status Quo

As much as it’s not for me, the majority of us love it. It’s not so much that we think that what we are currently doing is the “best” way to do something, rather that we know it works.

We favour the psychological safety of certainty. Humans at our core are naturally risk averse. Millions of years of harsh evolution has taught us to avoid risk and to play the long game based on what we know to be safe.

Status quo is comfortable because you know how something works, you understanding how it does (or doesn’t) impact you and you know with a high degree of certainty from your past experience what the results will be.

Work

New ideas carry with them the unknown. Since we aren’t sure exactly what will be required when we change to something new, not knowing the impact it will have on us creates a sense of discomfort.

In a broader context (implementing a new system at work for example), there is also the acknowledgment of the work or effort that will be required. Not only by an individual, but by different departments or teams.

The higher the perceived work effort, the more resistant people tend to be.

Even when they agree with the benefits, they cannot get away from the challenges the know they will face.

How It Makes Them Feel

I work in operations. In these environments you get a wide range of capabilities as you move through the organization.

People get used to what they do. They develop a mastery and that provides them with their sense of belonging and place within the organization.

Change can make people experience negative emotions. It can leave them feeling anxious, lose confidence, doubt the position they have established for themselves over the years.

Typically this will manifest as someone who hasn’t bought in or appears disengaged.

Reactance

This one has been getting more attention in literature lately. Reactance its simplest form is this — people don’t like being told what to do.

This forces people to perceive new opportunities as a threat versus the benefit we intend.

When someone feels pushed into or towards something, they will often push back equally hard. What’s more interesting is that even in the face of information contrary to their beliefs, reactance will force someone to dig in versus yield.

How To Effectively Get a New Idea Across or Implement a Change
  • Find opportunities to expose people to the change slowly
  • Familiarity breeds comfort — Comfort increases adoption
  • Make it easy for people to try or test a new idea or solution (free demos, trials, free account, etc)
  • Reduce as much as possible barriers or obstacles that they will see as a challenge towards adoption
  • Focus on people who seem disengaged. Ask that what changes they would make and why
  • Provide information and context so people can self-persuade
  • Stop telling them they have to change
  • Help them describe their future role or responsibilities


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Black Swan

  Maybe I think differently because I have read this? With everything going on with the CoronaVirus, it is incredible to see how people are behaving. Everyone and their cousin is talking about the Supply Chain, about being prepared, about not having enough capacity ... it's crazy. I honestly wonder if the people making all of these comments have ever actually ran any operations, if they ever had to responsibility to actually get things done. It's easy to say how prepared you can be, and what companies should have been doing, or pointing the finger saying "how could you be out of stock". The reality is, we have a lot of choice. The average grocery store for example can easily have 15,000 to 20, 000 skus that move through their stores ... think about that for a minute. That many skus, that are all cycling through the stores on some type of regular rate of sale.  Or let's take something that's more in people's face at the mo...

Give your best stuff away

    This is an interesting and sometimes polarizing topic. One group of people believe that the more content (ideas, conversations, posts, videos, etc) that you put out into the world, the better your return is as you are connecting with more people and getting greater exposure. Another group feels that by investing all of this energy into giving away "free stuff", takes away from what you could be doing to grow your business, give to your clients or to your employer. That giving your stuff away doesn't pay the bills, so what's really the point other than feeling good. For me personally, I'm all about giving my best stuff away for free, and what follows are really my "whys". First and foremost, I don't really prescribe to the idea that anyone really has "best stuff". That's finite and fixed and I truly don't believe this applies to people the way it can be associated to things. If you are a miner, and you m...

Growth & Success

  We spend so much of our time focused on results and outcomes. Did we win? Did we lose? Was it a success or a failure? How do we measure it? Track it? Compare it? Everyone wants to "succeed" because that is what we feel is the right answer. That is what gets praise from those all around us. It makes us feel valued and safe as it makes us feel like we have earned our place (at work or within our community). Does every step forward have to have the same outcome? At what point is the growth and learning just as (or even more?) valuable than some expected outcome? Our world is changing so quickly these days, more quickly than it probably ever has in the past. We have access to so much information, to so many more people and communities, we are constantly trying to "measure up" to everything around us. We are experiential creatures. Every experience that we have contributes to our knowledge and understanding our our-self and the world we are a part of and influences the...